If you’re into anal play, we don’t need to tell you just how pleasurable it can be. But unfortunately, there is still a stigma around anal play, and a belief that it is inherently painful.
And while it of course can be uncomfortable if done wrong, the same could be said for pleasuring every other area of the body. If you have the right equipment, and lots and lots of lube then you’re sure to experience a unique, earth-rumbling kind of pleasure!
But while prostate beads and your standard butt plugs are great and reliable toys that can provide that deep, earth-rumbling pleasure that makes anal play so exciting, butt plug tails add a lot more style to the proceedings. If they vibrate, then that’s even better!
From unicorns to wolves, to foxes and bunnies, here you’ll find our pick of the best vibrating butt plug tails. While some of our picks may not have vibrating capabilities, they’re still cute, fun butt plug tails that you’re sure to enjoy.
OUR TOP PICK
B-Vibe Unicore Vibrating Anal Toy With Tail
EDITORS CHOICE
Foxxy Fanny Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug
BEST VALUE
Happy Rabbit Vibrating Bunny Tail Butt Plug
OUR TOP PICK
B-Vibe Unicore Vibrating Anal Toy With Tail
Let’s kick things off with one magical butt plug tail! The B-Vibe Unicore Vibrating Anal Plug has a rainbow tail with all the strong and rumbly vibration you would want from a vibrating butt plug.
Whether you’re in the mood for a mellow rumble, or a vigorous buzz, there are 6 vibration patterns and 10 levels of intensity to explore.
The plug is made of entirely high-quality silicone that is silky smooth. It has an insertable length of 4.4in, perfect for everyday use if you feel like it!
The tapered tip makes it easy and comfortable to insert, and the spiral, textured design provides layers and layers of thrills.
The multicolor, synthetic unicorn tail is removable and is 19 inches in length, meaning you can also use this plug for a more dressed down session if you’re not feeling the unicorn look!
Plus, this just makes the tail so much easier to clean. You simply attach the butt plug to a magnetic pin.
But there are other treats to be had when you buy the B-Vibe Unicore Vibrating Anal Toy! You get a guide to anal play (handy if you’re a beginner), a guide to living your best unicorn life, a unicorn backpack, enamel pin, and glow-in-the-dark stickers.
This toy is limited edition so snatch it up quick!
Pros
- Strong, diverse vibration with 10 levels of intensity.
- Great for beginner and intermediate anal play.
- Textured design allows for twisting and tugging.
- Detachable tail makes washing easier.
- The tapered head makes insertion easier.
- Gender and neutral and can be enjoyed by anybody.
Cons
- Magnetic clip may come loose during play.
- While it is easy to wash, it is not totally waterproof. But it is splash-proof.
EDITORS CHOICE
Foxxy Fanny Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug
If you fancy yourself as a bit of a furry and enjoy a little vibration, look no further than the Foxxy Fanny Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug!
Not only is this tail just as plush as a fox’s tail, but with a generous amount of lube the plug is easy to insert, and will remain comfortable throughout your play.
The soft, smooth plug also comes with a looped bullet holder, and a strong battery-operated butt vibe to get your body thrumming with pleasure.
But the high-quality materials don’t just stop at the tail, as the butt plug itself is made of premium, non-porous silicone that is easy to clean.
This plug has an insertable length of 4 inches, is 1.4 inches in diameter, and has a total length of 19 inches.
Pros
- Varied vibration.
- Luxuriously soft tail.
- Comfortable insertion.
- Excellent for pet play.
Cons
- Vibration could be stronger.
- Vibe is battery-operated rather than rechargeable.
BEST VALUE
Happy Rabbit Vibrating Bunny Tail Butt Plug
There is no denying how sexy the bunny look is. Whether you think of Playboy bunnies with their fishnets and fluffy, white cottontails, or the rampant rabbits that stimulate your clit, bunny motifs have long been associated with feeling frisky.
Enter the cute Happy Rabbit Rechargeable Vibrating Bunny Tail. You’re sure to look cute and sexy with this fun butt plug.
Not only is it one of the more durable butt plug tails on our list, it has 12 exciting speeds and vibrations patterns to spice up your next session.
The base is also customizable, and you can choose from a bunny tail if you’re in the mood for pet play, and a sparkling, diamond insert when you’re not. Either way, you’re sure to always look glamorous while getting off!
As it has an insertable length of 5 inches with the same circumference, we would recommend this butt plug tail for those more experienced with anal play.
Pros
- Durable and comfortable.
- Fun, exciting vibration control.
- The flared base makes you feel safe and secure while wearing the plug.
Cons
- Might be too heavy for some.
- We would have appreciated a wireless remote for the vibration.
RUNNER UP
Frisky Faux Fur Fox Tail Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug
Our favorite thing about this Frisky Faux Fur Fox Tail is its stunning white color made from synthetic materials. But while this tail is undoubtedly cute, it packs quite the punch! The smooth rounded tip gradually opens up to a circumference of 4.5 inches.
You’re sure to have plenty of fun with this toy! It measures 20 inches in length, from the silicone tip to the tip of its fluffy tail. This means with a cheeky shake of your booty you can make the tail swish!
The vibration feature is entirely optional, and batteries are included.
Pros
- Super stylish.
- The bullet vibrator attached to the toy is detachable. You get two toys for the price of one!
- Able to swish the tail.
Cons
- Only has one vibration speed.
RUNNER UP
The DOMINIX Deluxe Faux Fox Tail
While this butt plug tail doesn’t vibrate, as it’s one of the most popular foxtail butt plugs we have to mention it. This faux fur tail with a stainless steel plug is sure to become a favorite for you too, thanks to the mind-blowing sensation when inserted.
The tail feels amazing when you run your fingers through it, and for some teasing before insertion, is great to brush against your inner thighs or perineum.
The toy has a total length of 14.5 inches, and you also have a range of size options for the plug, from 2.5 inches to 4 inches.
As the plug is metal, it is heavier than silicone or glass plugs, but it is still comfortable. In fact, you might enjoy the extra weight!
When you move it is particularly pleasurable. The metal surface also makes it ideal for temperature play, whether you want it warm or cold. Plus, it is a lot easier to insert.
Hygiene is always important, and luckily this plug is easy to clean by simply unscrewing the fox tail from the plug.
Pros
- Ideal for temperature play.
- Soft fur.
- The extra weight adds another sensation to the play.
- The tail is removable to make cleaning the plug easier.
- Super cute look.
Cons
- While the plug is easy to clean, the fur tail is a lot harder to clean especially when there is lube on it.
- The tail could be longer.
RUNNER UP
Cute Pom-Pom Butt Plugs By Blush Novelties
This pom-pom bunny cotton tail plug is both cute and sexy, transforming you into a naughty little bunny as soon as it’s inserted. The classic shape and soft silicone plug is sure to fill you up wonderfully and stays in place throughout your play.
This light, tapered plug is easy to insert, making it great for beginners, and introduces you to new sensations whether you’re enjoying partnered or solo play. The premium material of this plug is non-porous and can be easily cleaned.
Pros
- Easy insertion.
- Soft, high-quality faux for.
- Ideal for beginners.
- Ideal for animal play.
- Easy to clean.
Cons
- Doesn’t vibrate.
RUNNER UP
Tailz Puppy Play Set: Perfect For Puppy Play
While this butt plug tail doesn’t vibrate, this puppy butt plug tail is ideal for those who want to combine pet play with a little butt stimulation.
With a total length of 12.1 inches, an insertable length of 3.6 inches, and a tail length of 8.5 inches, this butt plug tail is sure to provide truly sensational play and get your tail wagging!
The bouncy texture of this tail that means every brush and stroke is sure to travel deep inside you and make you shiver. The medical-grade silicone is also completely waterproof, making it a breeze to clean.
With a generous amount of lube you can easily slide this puppy tail inside you and transform into a playful puppy in seconds!
Pros
- Unique design.
- Comfortable insertion.
- Medical-grade, waterproof silicone that is easy to clean and store.
- Large and wide for those into anal stretching.
Cons
- Might be too large for some people.
- Doesn’t vibrate.
RUNNER UP
Tailz Black Silicone Anal Plug With Wolf Tail (Grey)
From cute, obedient puppy to wild wolf! This wolf tail butt plug with an insertable length of 4 inches is sure to stretch and fill you in the best way possible and unleash your wild side!
For vaginal sex with this toy inserted in your anus we recommend riding your partner, you’re sure to both howl in pleasure.
The plug is classically shaped, and if you’re into anal stretching is well-sized enough to achieve a decent stretch. Our favorite part about this butt plug tail however, is the super long gray wolf tail that is super soft and plush.
Despite being faux fur it looks incredibly realistic, which speaks to its high-quality. Plus, with the cute headband you can go full wolf.
Pros
- Soft, high-quality fur tail.
- Value for money.
- Ideal for anal stretching.
- Comes with a wolf-ear headband for extra immersion in role play scenarios.
Cons
- You’ll need plenty of lube to insert this butt plug.
RUNNER UP
Crystal Delights My Lil Rainbow Pony Tail
Admit it, we all fantasize about a rainbow butt plug, and with this rainbow pony tail butt plug all your pet play dreams can come true!
This is a truly high-quality butt plug tail, made of durable borosilicate glass. Much like metal butt plugs, glass plugs are great for hot or cold temperature play. Insertion is also surprisingly easy, and the glass material is comfortable to wear throughout your play.
The plug has an insertable length of 2.8 inches and a width of 1.3 inches. While we love the rainbow color, you can also choose between blue, pink, and lavender shades.
Pros
- Available in a variety of colors.
- Ideal for temperature play.
- The tail is made of high-quality materials and is detachable, making it easy to clean.
- Glass anal plug is handcrafted.
- Easy insertion.
Cons
- A bit on the expensive side.
RUNNER UP
Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug
This short, bunny tail has a hot pink hue that is sure to make you stand out amongst the other bunnies!
The Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug has an insertable length of 2.5 inches, and a circumference of 3.5 inches, making it ideal for beginners. The bright pink color gives it a fun look. Great for those who don’t like to take themselves too seriously!
The bunny tail is short and sweet, and the total length of the whole toy is 5 inches. If you’re a beginner, this is a reassuring toy to use for your first time, as this toy isn’t intimidating in the slightest.
Plus, the butt plug is made of safe silicone and is pretty flexible.
Insertion is easy thanks to the comfortable tapered bulb shape. The silicone also stays warm throughout your play for extra comfort.
While this butt plug tail is great for beginners, as it’s only available in hot pink it may not be for everybody. We would have been even more pleased with this butt plug tail if it came in a wider variety of colors.
Pros
- Good dimensions for beginners.
- Fun, playful hot pink shade.
- Silicone is soft and warm.
Cons
- Only available in hot pink.
Final Thoughts
We hope that our above picks have inspired you to incorporate a little buzz into your pet play, and vibrating butt plug tails are the best way to do that in style.
For some intense vibration we recommend the B-Vibe Unicore and the Happy Rabbit Large Rechargeable Vibrating Bunny Tail Butt Plug, while for a sensational stretch we recommend the Tailz Black Silicone Anal Plug with Wolf Tail and The DOMINIX Deluxe Faux Fox Tail.
But whether you want to be a cute bunny or puppy dog, a magical unicorn, or a fierce wolf, why not add some good vibrations to your pet play with these vibrating butt plug tails?
