Best Tail Butt Plugs

Tailed butt plugs are a great way to spice up your sex life. Fun and kinky, a tailed butt plug is the perfect addition to any kinkster’s toolkit. 

If you’re unfamiliar with what they are, a tailed butt plug is a variation on the popular anal toy. As the name suggests, their appeal comes from the animal (or other creature) tail attached to the toy itself.

Tailed butt plugs are popular for several reasons. First of all, they add a twist to an already great toy. With the addition of a tail, there is a better grip if you want to adjust the plug while it’s inside. It also makes it easier to shift and wriggle the plug, if that’s something you enjoy.

Another appeal of a butt plug with a tail is the extra bit of kinkiness it brings.

Not only are tail butt plugs the perfect choice for anyone interested in pet play (where one or more of the participants roleplays with animalistic traits), but they are also a kinkier option if you enjoy anal play and want to push the boat out a bit further. 

Like all sex toys, you want your tail butt plug to be high-quality product, making sure you have a safe and fun time.

But with the wide range of tail butt plugs on the market, how do you know you’re buying a hygienic and good quality toy?

Luckily, we’ve done the legwork and found 10 of the best tail butt plugs out there. Not only that, but we’ve also weighed up the pros and cons of each one, to help you pick the best tail butt plug for you.

What Types Of Butt Plug Are There?

Tailed butt plugs come in all shapes and sizes. Different models have different features, styles, and designs. And of course, the tails are based off of all sorts of different animals (fictional and otherwise). Here’s a quick breakdown of some of the plugs you might find.

The main attraction of a tail butt plug is (fairly obviously) the tail itself. There are plugs modeled after almost every animal that exists, as well as some that don’t. 

Among the most popular animals to inspire tail butt plugs are cats, wolves, and foxes. These are some of the most common designs you’ll find when looking for the perfect plug, but there are some much more surprising animals that make the list.

While rabbit tails may not be too much of a shocker, horse tails may surprise you more. Nonetheless, horse tail butt plugs (made of strands of rubber or silicone) are increasing in popularity. 

Other examples include cow tails and pig tails, both of which have roots set a bit more firmly in kink and fetish communities.

There are also plenty of fictional creatures who have lent their tails to the world of butt plugs. Unicorns and creatures from pop culture are just a few examples - like we said earlier, there are tail butt plugs for nearly every animal out there, as well as some that aren’t.

Like any other butt plug, a tail butt plug can come in a range of shapes and sizes. 

Typically, a tail butt plug will have a flared base that the tail is attached to. The plug itself tends to be a cone or teardrop shape, and will be around 3-4 inches long and 1-2 inches wide. Of course, though, you can find tail butt plugs in all shapes and sizes.

There are also plenty of features to be found in a tail butt plug. These vary from the practical (such as a detachable base to make cleaning the toy easier), to the luxurious (like a vibrating plug).

With the addition of the tail, these butt plugs have much more to work with, so keep an eye out for any fun features that stand out to you.

So now that we’ve taken a little look at what tail butt plugs are and what they’re for, let’s take a look at the 10 best tail butt plugs on the market!

OUR TOP PICK

The DOMINIX Deluxe Faux Fox Tail

Starting off this list strong, the Dominix Deluxe Fox Tail butt plug is perfect for someone experienced in anal play who wants to spice things up a bit more. 

This plug is fairly large, with a length of 4 inches. It’s also pretty heavy due to its stainless steel material. That said, this just makes it feel much more filling and satisfying when it’s in.

The tail itself is comfortable and soft, with its faux fur perfectly mimicking a real fox’s tail.

Meanwhile, the rigid steel of the plug can be warmed up to make it more comfortable when inserted, or you could use the cold to your advantage with some sensitive temperature-play.

As simple as this plug may look at first, its quality and potential make it a guaranteed hit in the bedroom.

What We Like

  • Made from stainless steel and faux fur, this tail butt plug is waterproof and allergen-free
  • With a total length of 16.5 inches, this tail is the perfect length for holding or tugging
  • You can unscrew the tail from the plug to make cleaning easy

What Could Be Better

  • The metal will need to be warmed up before use, unless it’s being used for temperature play
  • At 4 inches and almost 15 ounces, this plug is on the larger side

EDITORS CHOICE

Crystal Delights My Lil Rainbow Pony Tail

Want something a little more colorful? Then look no further than this fabulous unicorn tail butt plug. This glass plug uses brightly colored, high-grade wig hair to make this tail soft and smooth against the skin.

Its material isn’t the only great quality the tail has. The tail naturally forms a gentle curl, helping it maintain its beautiful flowing appearance. It’s also removable from the rest of the plug, and can be washed easily with warm water and soap.

Simply rinse it with cold water flowing the same way as the tail, and you have a clean and tangle-free tail!

Whether you want to live out your unicorn fantasy, or just want to add a splash of color to your plug, this is the butt plug for you.

What We Like

  • With each plug being made by hand, every colorful tail is different
  • The extra-strong borosilicate glass is built to reduce the risk of breaks and makes the plug easier to insert
  • The tail itself is also high-quality, made of high-grade synthetic wig hair that keeps it swishing softly

What Could Be Better

  • Avoiding dust and tangles can be a hassle if you don’t take proper care of the tail 
  • Because every plug is handcrafted individually, they are on the pricier side and best suited for someone serious about exploring tail butt plugs

BEST VALUE

Tailz Black Silicone Anal Plug With Wolf Tail (Grey)

If you’re looking for more than just a plug, you’re in luck. This wolf tail butt plug from TAILZ also comes with a matching pair of wolf ears to help you push your kinky experience even further.

The tail is soft, fluffy, and super-long with a total length of 23.5 inches. But while this length means the tail will dangle down while you’re wearing it, the high-quality faux fur isn’t itchy or uncomfortable. 

At 4.5 inches long and 1.75 inches wide, this plug is longer and thinner than many of the other plugs on this list. This makes it ideal for beginners to butt plugs and anal play, and is easier to insert.

However, because it’s made of silicone you won’t be able to use any silicone-based lubes.

What We Like

  • Its soft and fluffy fur makes it comfortable and fun to wear
  • The plug also comes with matching ears, letting you enhance your pet play further

What Could Be Better

  • Because the plug is made of silicone it isn’t compatible with silicone-based lubes, so you’ll need to use an alternative
  • The tail can be hard to clean, as it isn’t detachable from the base. Silicone is also harder to clean than metal or glass toys

RUNNER UP

Crystal Delights Bunny Tail Butt Plug

Sometimes simple is best, and this understated rabbit tail butt plug shows that even the smallest tail can pack a lot of great sensations. This basic but effective butt plug is perfect for both experienced and amateur kinksters alike.

This fluffy bunny tail butt plug is smaller than most butt plugs, making it perfect for anyone who just wants to dip their toes into the world or tail butt plugs.

Meanwhile, the strong glass is perfect for temperature play and can be heated or cooled in a bowl of water. When you need to clean your toy, simply remove the tail from the base by sliding away the magnet that connects them.

With the choice of either bright white or candyfloss pink, you’re sure to look great while wearing this cute plug. And if you enjoy your experience, why not venture a bit deeper with some of the other tail butt plugs on this list?

What We Like

  • The smaller plug makes this tail butt plug suitable for beginners to anal play
  • Its strong and durable borosilicate glass can be heated or cooled easily
  • You can remove the tail from the plug by sliding off the handy magnet

What Could Be Better

  • Because of how small the tail is, there isn’t really anywhere to grip or hold
  • White is a riskier color for your toy, and the tail may look dirty over time

RUNNER UP

Foxxy Fanny Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug

The Foxxy Fanny Tail Butt Plug is sure to cause a buzz with its built-in vibrator.

Made of hypoallergenic silicone, the cone-shaped plug stays secure and firm once it has been inserted. Not only that, but the 4-inch insertable length is longer than a standard plug. 

The long, white tail is as stunning as it is fluffy, while the peanut vibe in the plug can be removed to suit your preferences.

This butt plug is best for anyone who enjoys anal play but wants to get more out of their toys. If normal butt plugs aren’t enough, you can add even more sensations by using the vibrator setting.

Alternatively, the long tail is perfect for tugging if you want to make things a bit rougher.

What We Like

  • A small (yet powerful) peanut vibrator gives the plug an extra layer of pleasure
  • The long white tail is made of premium materials and is incredibly fluffy
  • The addition of a loop around the base makes the plug much easier to remove

What Could Be Better

  • There is only one speed setting on the vibrator, and you need to replace the batteries when they run out
  • The tail itself isn’t detachable, making cleaning more difficult

RUNNER UP

Tailz Puppy Play Set Perfect For Puppy Play

Puppy play has gotten an upgrade with this set from TAILZ. While the dog tail butt plug is the main attraction, this multi-toy set has everything you need to push your pet play to the fullest.

The butt plug is made from a flexible silicone, with a standard-sized plug that makes it suitable for nearly all levels of experience.

The tail is curved, and also made of silicone. This shape makes it easy to adjust or play with the tail while the plug is inserted, and the flared base is inconspicuous and stays out of sight.

But as well as the dog tail butt plug, this set also includes a bone gag, a collar, and an attachable leash.

All of these products are great quality - the gag is adjustable with a firm but soft silicone bone, and the collar has a cushioned inside to make wearing it comfortable even over long periods. To top it all off, you also get a carry case to store everything.

Why settle for one toy, when this set has it all?

What We Like

  • The selection of toys is a welcome bonus to a great butt plug, and helps complete the puppy-play package
  • Its flexible silicone butt plug is visually and functionally stimulating, and is suitable for all levels of experience in anal play
  • The materials are hypoallergenic and easy to clean

What Could Be Better

  • The tail’s shape and the base of the plug means you can’t twist it once it’s inside
  • Because the plug is made of silicone, it can need more lube and may be harder to insert

RUNNER UP

Alluring Dominix Glass Faux Fur Cat Tail Butt Plug

Another great butt plug from DOMINIX, but this one mimicking a cat’s tail. The faux fur is the same high-grade material as the fox tail; however, this cat tail is made of a fluffy, flowing black fur.

Another difference is the plug itself - the DOMINIX Faux Cat Tail Butt Plug is made of a stunning black glass that slides in smoothly without a hitch.

Its tapered teardrop shape means it is easy to insert but stays secure once it’s in. Add in a soft and smooth tail and you’re left with the perfect toy for cat lovers.

Although the glass plug is lighter than the stainless steel one, this plug will still leave you feeling full and stuffed.

What We Like

  • The black fur adds a layer of mystery and intrigue to this tail
  • Its strong black glass is both visually striking and designed for easy insertion
  • The long tail is easy to grab and tug during sex for even more pleasure

What Could Be Better

  • You can’t detach the tail from the base, making it more difficult to clean
  • The plug’s size makes it less suitable for beginners

RUNNER UP

B-Vibe Unicore Vibrating Anal Toy With Tail

Live out your unicorn fantasy with b-Vibe’s Unicorn Tail Plug Set. Like that TAILZ Puppy Play Set, this collection of unicorn-themed toys and accessories has everything you need to fulfill all your dreams.

The silicone plug is much longer than usual, at 5.3 inches. It also has a light corkscrew texture for added pleasure while inserting and removing the plug.

On top of that, the plug also contains a powerful and versatile vibrator, with 10 vibration intensities and 6 vibration patterns - more than you could ever ask for!

But of course, the 19-inch detachable tail is the star of the show. It is made out of faux hair, and is attached to the base by a magnet. The tail comes in beautiful rainbow colors, with a natural twist accentuating the tail’s shape. Truly magical.

Not only do you get the unicorn tail butt plug itself, but the set also includes things like a Guide to Anal Play and a cute bag to help carry your set around.

What We Like

  • You can choose from a plethora of different strengths and settings in the powerful vibrator
  • The dashing rainbow tail is attached by a magnet and is easily removable
  • Its tapered design and unique texture make this plug one-of-a-kind

What Could Be Better

  • Because of this butt plug’s length and design, it may not be suitable for beginners 
  • If you’re only interested in the plug, then this set may be a bit on the pricey side

RUNNER UP

Cow Tail Butt Plug By Vuzara

Cow tail butt plugs have been increasing in popularity in recent years, and with this cute tail it isn’t hard to see why.

At a whopping 25” long, this tail is the perfect length to grab, tug, or swing for maximum pleasure. The cow print pattern is also attractive, while the tail has a good thickness to it. You can even detach the tail entirely when you’re cleaning your plug, making it as easy as possible.

Available in both metal and silicone, and in a range of sizes, this tail is perfect for whenever you’re in the ‘moo’d!

What We Like

  • With its long tail, this plug is easy to hold. It’s also easy to see when it’s in, making it clear when it’s time for some fun
  • This length also means the tail can be swayed or tugged to make it even more pleasurable
  • You can choose from a variety of sizes in either metal or silicone depending on your personal preference

What Could Be Better

  • The length and weight of this 25-inch long tail can be cumbersome and even uncomfortable if you aren’t used to the feeling
  • You can’t always be certain of the quality of sex toys bought off of sites like Etsy. While the reviews of a product can be great, there is less regulation of these toys which you need to be wary of

RUNNER UP

PIKY Butt Plug

Do you want to let your geeky side shine through in the bedroom? Well, Geeky Sex Toy’s Pokémoan collection is here to get the job done.

While other members of the video game-inspired collection are all dildos, this Pikachu tail (known as ‘Piky’) takes its place as one of the best pop-culture butt plugs ever designed.

The plug measures 1.6 inches tall and 1 inch wide, making it the smallest plug on this list. But like its inspiration, this plug’s small size doesn’t stop it from packing a punch.

What We Like

  • The iconic shape of this tail matches with the comfortable teardrop-shaped plug
  •  With the whole toy made of silicone, it’s easy to clean
  • Just put this plug in and watch the sparks fly

What Could Be Better

  • The tail itself is quite rigid and isn’t suitable for some positions
  • With a total length of 5 inches long, this small plug may not be enough

Final Thoughts

So now you’ve taken a look at some of the best tail butt plugs out there. Whether you choose one of the plugs on this list or find the best choice yourself, the variety of great tail butt plugs on the market makes sure there is something perfect for everyone.

Best Tail Butt Plugs

You don’t need to be a furry or into pet play to enjoy these toys (although it definitely doesn’t hurt!). There is plenty to love about tail butt plugs whatever your preferences, from their appearance, to their functionality.

No matter which style, design, or tail you want to go with, a tail butt plug is certain to spice your love life and introduce a new, kinkier side to anal play. With all that said and done, the only thing left for you to do now is choose the best tail butt plug for you.

Have fun!

Marissa White