Best Horse Tail Butt Plug

It can be hard to imagine yourself buying and using one of these items, you might think, that can’t possibly be something I would do... But, given the chance, you might find that a horse tail butt plug is exactly what you need in order to spice up your stagnant bedroom life.

Perhaps you are finally ready to explore a kinky interest you have kept secret for a long time, or maybe you just want to replace one of your old horse tail butt plugs. 

Regardless of whether you are already into pony play, or perhaps you are simply looking for a way to spice up the bedroom.

Regardless of which one you are, in this article, we will be looking at a few of the best horse tail butt plugs on the market. So, without further ado, let us dive right in. 


Anticipation USA - Horse Hair Butt Plug

This product is handmade, so the greatest care is taken in each horse tail butt plug. Real horse hair is used in making this product, so those of you that would prefer a vegan option may find that this product is not quite right for you.

If you are not bothered by this fact, the horse hair feels and looks natural. In addition to that, there is no latex in this product, so those of you with allergies should be safe. 

We found that this product was overall very well-made and looked amazing. The real horse hair really did a lot in making this product both look and feel great. 


  • Real Horse Hair - The use of real horse hair makes this product look and feel realistic. Because it is natural, it is less likely to cause irritation to the skin. 
  • Colors - There are a variety of colors to choose from, including, various shades of black, brown, or sorrel. 
  • Plug Size - You can decide between four glass plug sizes for this product, small, medium, large, and extra-large. 
  • For Any Experience Level - Because you have a variety of sizes to pick from, this product is great for novices and experts alike. 
  • Handmade - Care has been put into crafting each butt plug tail, so each one is well-made and durable, so they can withstand most forms of play. 


  • Not Vegan - This product uses real horse hair to make the tail, so if you live a vegan lifestyle or this does not sit right with you, this product will not be the one for you. 


Spank U Toys - Vegan Pony Tail Butt Plug

The spank u toys’ pony tail butt plug is a well-made and attractive-looking toy with several features that really make it stand out. It is a handmade product which assures each tail is quality controlled and durable.

This product allows you to choose out of three plug sizes you would like, small, medium, and large. So, it is suitable for beginners and experienced people alike. 

We found that this product was well-made, and we really enjoyed the fact that the materials that were used were vegan-friendly.

In addition to that, the fact that the tail and plug are detachable means that this product can be cleaned and sterilized easily. Overall, the Spank U Toys’ pony tail butt plug is a great product to have that is sure to spice up your bedroom. 


  • Vegan Friendly - The hair used for the tail part of this product is synthetic and vegan friendly and brought over from ethical sources. 
  • The Look - This product looks great, the tail is full and not too thin. The colors are natural and fun to look at. Overall, making this a great-looking pony tail butt plug. 
  • Detachable - The tail and the butt plug are detachable, so you can clean each part separately, assuring that everything is sterile and clean after each use. 
  • Hand Made - Each item is made by hand, assuring quality for each horse/pony tail butt plug that is made. 
  • Discreet Packaging - The manufacturer assures that each product that you buy is packaged discreetly, so if you want to keep your purchase to yourself, you do not have to worry about oddly shaped packages giving you away. 


  • Synthetic Hair - May cause allergies, so make sure you know what fiber is used in this product to avoid a reaction.


SPORK Wood - Pony Tail Butt Plug

This flashy and colorful pony tail butt plug not only looks long and luscious, but it is also customizable. This manufacturer allows you to choose between three different sizes, small, medium, or large. So, you can decide what works best for you,

We found that this product was well-made and looked fantastic as well. The lack of natural colors was a bit disappointing, however, if you want a dark and light blue pony tail this product might be just right for you.

We loved the option to select the plug sizes, this allows you to be able to pick based on what you are comfortable with right from the get-go. Overall, the SPORK Wood pony tail butt plug is a great purchase and an even greater addition to the bedroom. 


  • Vegan Friendly - The materials used to make this product are synthetic, and by extension, they are vegan friendly. 
  • Plug Size Options - If you buy this product, you will have the option to select between three plug sizes, thus allowing you to comfortably choose what suits you.
  • Handmade - Each tail is handmade by SPORK Wood, as such each tail is made with care and attention to detail. Allowing for high-quality products. 
  • Steel Plug - This pony tail butt plug has a steel plug that is comfortable, safe, and great for sensation play if you warm or cool it down before inserting it. 
  • Toy Care - The manufacturer offers a guide on how to care for this toy properly, this will allow you to make sure your product lasts a long time with the right care. 


  • Color Variety - There are not many color options available for this product, in fact, there is only a dark blue and light blue tail available. 
  • Synthetic Materials - It is not clear what the hair is made of, as such you will need to check, so you can avoid any allergic reaction should it be made of materials you are sensitive to. 


Cypress Emporium - Pony Tail Butt Plug

This is a simple yet functional pony/horse tail butt plug. The hair is brunette, long, and silky to the touch, and the plug is small and well-shaped to make insertion easier.

Best of all, the plug is free of Phthalate, so anyone who is sensitive to this material should be safe to use this product.

We found that this product was relatively well-made, looked the part, and had several features that really made this a great product.

The hair on the tail was a little thinner than anticipated, but as a whole, it appeared more-a-less like the product image, so there was not too much to complain about. 


  • The Look - The hair looks soft, and is a nice natural color. 
  • Plug - The plug is small and easy to insert, making it a great product for beginners.
  • Handmade - Because each item is handmade, each product is carefully put together, ensuring great quality products. 


  • Not Detachable - The tail does not detach from the plug, which can make cleaning a little tougher than it needs to be after use. 
  • Variety - There are not a lot of choices when it comes to color and plug size, for this pony tail butt plug you get a brown tail and a small silicone butt plug.


Krystail Official - Horse Tail Butt Plug

This elegant horse tail butt plug is a great pick if you want to spice up your bedroom. Not only is this product a tail plug, but it is also a gem at the base of the plug. The tail is made out of faux hair, so the product should be safe for vegan use. 

We found that this product was not only elegant and pretty with the added gem, but it was also designed in a way that made the product easy to use.

The classic teardrop shape of the plug makes insertion easy and makes this horse tail butt plug suitable for beginners and intermediates alike. The lightweight nature of this product only adds to the comfort factor and appeal of the overall product.

This makes the Krystail Official horse tail butt plug a fantastic choice when it comes to spicing up your adult toy collection. 


  • Handmade - Each item is hand made and as such the quality control is high, assuming that the product you receive will be of excellent quality. 
  • Faux Hair - Faux fur is used for the tail, making this a great product for those of you that are looking out for the environment or living a vegan lifestyle. 
  • Discreet packaging - The packaging for this product is discreet, so no one will know what you have purchased.
  • The Look - This horse tail butt plug looks elegant, and the hair appears to be soft to the touch. It also comes with a gemstone on the plug, which really gives it that extra shine. 


  • Not Detachable - The plug does not detach from the tail, which can make cleaning this product a little more challenging. However, the manufacturer provides instructions on how to care for this product. 
  • The Hair - Not as thick as you would hope, but it still looks the part and is a great overall product. 


Uniquelicious Co - Rainbow Pony Tail Butt Plug

This fun and flirty rainbow pony butt plug is a pretty and unique product. Not only does it have a  colorful and luscious synthetic equine tail, but it also has a great silicone butt plug which is designed for easy insertion for both beginners and experienced folks. 

We found that overall, this product is really well-made, the fact that it is handmade ensures the best quality and detail for each product.

The fun colors for the horse tail only adds to the appeal, and we found that the synthetic fibers that were used really added to the overall appeal.

The main downside to this product, in particular, was the fact that the tail was not able to detach from the plug nor are you able to choose what size you would like. 


  • The Look - This tail is unique, flirty, and fun, the colorful tail is a great statement piece and certainly stands out in comparison to a realistic-looking horse tail. 
  • Plug  - The plug is small and easy to insert, meaning this will be a great product for beginners and more experienced people. 
  • Handmade - This product is handmade and as such assures an excellent level of quality for each pony tail butt plug that you purchase from Uniquelicious Co. 


  • Not Detachable - The tail is not detachable from the plug, this may make cleaning and sanitizing a little tougher than it needs to be. 
  • Plug Size - You will not have the option to select the size of your plug, instead you will receive the standard smaller size. 


Lovely Thinkings - Horse Tail Butt Plug

This product uses real horse hair in its construction, this gives this horse tail butt plug a great, natural look and feel. This might however mean that this product will not be suitable for those of you living a vegan lifestyle.

The Lovely Thinkings’ horse tail butt plug is a great product that is not only designed to look elegant and classy but also designed for comfort.

The plug is made of solid stainless steel, which means that any type of lube can be used for this product, as well as it is easy to sanitize. 

We found that the Lovely Thinkings’ Horse Tail Butt Plug was well-made and elegant.  The fact that you are able to choose whether you would like a medium or a large plug for the tail is a great feature that allows people to comfortably choose what suits them best.

Overall, this is a great purchase and one that you are not likely to regret, adding to your adult toy collection. 


  • Look and Feel - The tail looks and feels realistic, the real horse hair really adds to this feature and makes this product appear elegant and natural. 
  • Plug Size - You are able to pick between a medium and a large plug, so, you are able to select a size that suits your experience and comfort level while using this product. 
  • Lube - Because this product's butt plug is stainless steel, you are able to use any lube on it. So, any of you with allergies to specific kinds of lube should have a great time using this toy. 
  • Handmade - The fact that this product is handmade means that you are assured care in the creation of every product, meaning you will receive a horse tail butt plug that is made to withstand the rigorous paces you might put it through.


  • Tail Thickness - The hair of this tail is not as thick as some others might look, so if you want a horse tail butt plug that is full, then this might not be the perfect product for you.
  • Not Vegan Friendly - This product is made of real horse hair, as such if you observe a vegan lifestyle this may not be the best product for you. 

Final Thoughts

Best Horse Tail Butt Plug

Not only can horse tail butt plugs be a fun toy to try out, but they might be the beginning of a new sexual adventure.

Whether you want to try out something new, rekindle an old kinky flame, or simply replace a much-loved horse tail butt plug, we have done our best to aid you on your delightfully kinky sexual adventures. 

Marissa White